Three things to know about a National government and property investors

Three things to know about a National government and property investor…

0 개 1,129 KoreaPost

By CoreLogic NZ Chief Property Economist, Kelvin Davidson

·         A shorter Brightline Test may entice investment buyers, but probably also some sellers who would be off the hook for capital gains tax earlier than expected

·         Softer foreign buyer rules is a lesser known entity given uncertainty around how many would buy in NZ, and the limited stock at the ‘top end’

·         Reinstatement of 100% interest deductibility would benefit existing investors and maybe boost investor sentiment – but low yields and high mortgage rates would still mean running losses for the ‘average’ investment purchase

·         There are bigger picture restraints still in play, regardless of election result – such as stretched affordability and ‘higher for longer’ mortgage rates

Many existing and would-be property investors will be keeping a close watch on the polls and whether or not National can form/lead the next government – which we now know would mean a reinstatement of mortgage interest deductibility for all properties, a Brightline Test back at two years (rather than the five or 10 system at present), and a softening of the foreign buyer ban. But what will the overall impact of these changes be? This Pulse takes a look at some of the issues surrounding potential housing/tax policy changes.

1. Brightline

There’s been a lot of focus on the possible buying implications of a shorter Brightline test from July 2024. Some investors would no doubt be tempted to make their first purchase or expand their existing portfolio by the reduced risk of having to pay capital gains tax if they needed to then sell within a short horizon. But what about the selling side? There are likely to be some existing investors struggling a bit with cashflow at present given higher mortgage rates, but who don’t want to sell because a large capital gains tax bill would be even worse. If they suddenly found themselves off the hook for that bill, some extra listings and sales could follow soon after.


   


2. Foreign buyers

There’s the potential new ability for foreign buyers to purchase NZ properties with a price of $2m or greater, albeit with a 15% tax attached. On one hand, there’s no real way of knowing how many of them might actually target NZ, and for context we estimate that only about 3% of our housing stock has a value of $2m or more. Then again, the shorter Brightline Test would add some appeal, and there may also be greater effects in areas that we already know are popular with foreign buyers, such as Queenstown where about 10% of properties are valued at $2m+.The extra demand could just exacerbate the shortages of stock at ‘affordable’ prices that already exist.

On a side note, National’s estimated annual tax take from foreign buyers is $740m. But that seems pretty ambitious. For example, there have been around 2,600 sales at $2m+ in the past year, and if you assume 5% of those went to foreign buyers at an average price of $3m, the tax would only raise roughly $60m. In some ways, to make National’s figures ‘work’, you have to assume that the large majority of sales above $2m would go to foreign buyers – which seems unlikely.

3. Interest deductibility

There’s the possible reinstatement of full mortgage interest deductibility over a phased period, with 50% this tax year and 2024/25, 75% in 2025/26, and back to 100% in 2026/27. On this particular change, we think the idea that it would open the floodgates for investors to purchase again is probably wide of the mark. To illustrate this, we’ve run some simple investment return numbers in the table below (which assumes either 0% or 100% deductibility).

2489e16bea239453e593310bbd25313d_1693965665_9518.jpg
 

As you can see, there’s a before-tax cashflow loss each year of around $19,300 in this scenario. Then there’s tax. Given those interest costs aren’t deductible for an existing property in the current system, that actual loss now turns into a taxable profit, which results in an extra bill of around $5,500 (at a 33% tax rate). All told, the required top-up out of other income to keep the property going in this scenario is $477 every week.

At this stage, let’s factor in 100% deductibility again. Holding everything else the same, the weekly top-up drops to $371. Now, that saving is not to be sniffed at, and of course property investors have always tended to be willing to accept cashflow losses in the early stages of their horizon, with the pay-off being rental growth and capital gains later.

It also needs to be acknowledged that these calculations are fairly simple (e.g. excluding depreciation allowances), and in reality some investors might be able to achieve a rental yield higher than 3.5% for example (or get a bargain price, or save on maintenance, etc). Certainly, some investors are still making it work right now, with the CoreLogic Buyer Classification data showing that mortgaged Multiple Property Owners still account for about 21% of purchases.


   


But even with all of that in mind, a $371 top-up every week is still substantial, even with deductibility added back in. The sums get even trickier if the would-be investor is factoring in lower potential capital gains in future than we’ve seen in the past.

Now, let’s be clear that there’ll still be property investors making purchases and getting the sums to work (as they are now) – and that’s necessary, given we’ll always need more rental stock to cater for a growing population. Indeed, rising rents at the moment highlight potential shortages of available stock might already be emerging, and that in turn could help entice some investors back. And even just the ‘mindset effect’ of a change in tax rules could have a similar effect – especially if investors are also concerned that they might not be able to buy at all if/when caps on debt to income ratios for mortgage lending are imposed next year.

However, the key point is that the biggest challenge for making the sums work on purchasing an existing property as an investment at present isn’t the lack of mortgage interest deductibility; it’s actually the large negative gap between rental yields and mortgage rates (and significant top-ups). As such, although some investors would enjoy a mood/sentiment shift, and may be tempted into a purchase by a National victory, we doubt it’ll be a game-changer.

Of course, the reinstatement of full mortgage interest deductions would certainly be welcomed by existing property investors, given it’s a direct boost to their profits. It’s certainly worth noting that those that have been in the game for a longer period haven’t really been as affected by the phased removal of deductibility anyway, and haven’t been selling to any great degree. But some extra cash would obviously be a solid boost for them anyway.

What it all means

Overall, if National won the election and made these policy changes, the reduced incentives to buy new-builds (although the LVR system would still tend to favour them because of lower deposit requirements) would tend to see demand rise for existing properties relative to new stock – with associated price effects. Indeed, there is some evidence to suggest that a new-build premium has opened up a bit in recent years, which could then go into reverse.

More generally, the combined effect of the changes could result in higher house prices than otherwise would have been the case, but perhaps not to a significant degree in aggregate. After all, affordability is still stretched, rental yields low, and mortgage rates high. Caps on debt to income ratios remain on the cards for 2024 too.

All that said, however, there’s always the risk of adverse consequences, and a stronger price effect couldn’t be totally ruled out, especially if foreign buyers targeted a market such as Queenstown.

ENDS

Source: CoreLogic NZ

Clearer picture emerging of housing damage

댓글 0 | 조회 1,016 | 2023.02.10
Repair options are being assessed for the now 543 public houses damaged in the Auckland floods.Deputy Chief Executive for Auckland and Northland Carol… 더보기

Opinion: We may not see a property investor c…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,182 | 2023.02.09
By CoreLogic NZ Chief Property Economist Kelvin DavidsonThere’s been an increasing number of hurdles placed in front of property investors in the past… 더보기

Big Tech Survey reveals technology uptake in …

댓글 0 | 조회 677 | 2023.02.07
The Auckland Business Chamber’s Big Tech Survey has found that one of the most important tasks for small and medium businesses in 2023 is to stay ahea… 더보기

Business Credit Demand in negative territory …

댓글 0 | 조회 947 | 2023.02.03
Equifax NZ Quarterly Business Credit Demand Index: December 2022- Overall business credit enquiries down -1.7% (vs December 2021 quarter)- Business lo… 더보기

No reprieve for persistent property price fal…

댓글 0 | 조회 961 | 2023.02.01
Aotearoa New Zealand’s housing market downturn continues to roll on, with CoreLogic’s House Price Index recording a 0.3% fall in January, the 10thcons… 더보기

Severe weather impact across the Auckland are…

댓글 0 | 조회 2,104 | 2023.01.29
A state of local emergency has been declared for Auckland due to severe weather causing unprecedented flooding across the region.If life, health or pr… 더보기

Storm event updates: Sunday 29 January

댓글 0 | 조회 1,745 | 2023.01.29
Heavy rain watch for todayWe currently have a Heavy Rain Watch in place from this morning through until 6am Monday. This may be revised later today (S… 더보기

Home lending demand down across all regions f…

댓글 0 | 조회 873 | 2023.01.23
Equifax NZ Quarterly Consumer Credit Demand Index: December Quarter 2022● Overall consumer credit demand reduced by -7.7 % (vs December qtr 2021).● Mo… 더보기

SNAP POLL: Hipkins clear voter favourite for …

댓글 0 | 조회 801 | 2023.01.21
SNAP POLL: Hipkins clear voter favourite for Labour Party leadership raceFollowing Thursday’s surprise announcement by Jacinda Ardern that she will be… 더보기

Are double-digit construction price rises fin…

댓글 0 | 조회 697 | 2023.01.16
The average cost of building a home in New Zealand’s main centres increased by 11.3% last year, but the good news is that the rising cost of construct… 더보기

New Zealand LVRs not likely to be loosened th…

댓글 0 | 조회 847 | 2023.01.16
Early this year I was quotedin an articlethat explored how the country’s housing market might change if the current ‘artificial’ restrictions were tak… 더보기

Mapping the Market plots a testing year for N…

댓글 0 | 조회 804 | 2022.12.20
Aotearoa’s lifestyle and more affordable housing markets are among only a handful of suburbs to have defied the national property market downturn, as … 더보기

GDP increases 2.0 percent in the September 20…

댓글 0 | 조회 815 | 2022.12.15
Gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 2.0 percent in the September 2022 quarter, following a revised 1.9 percent rise in the June 2022 quarter, Stats N… 더보기

New Zealand's 2022 property market downturn d…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,514 | 2022.12.15
CoreLogic's annual Best of the Best Report sums up 2022 market performanceThe New Zealand property market has experienced a bigger downturn in propert… 더보기

Asian parents more concerned about prejudice …

댓글 0 | 조회 1,655 | 2022.12.14
● 8 out of 10 parents say their children are impacted by at least one physical or mental health related issue● More than half (54%) of all parents wor… 더보기

Watch those lithium-ion batteries this Christ…

댓글 0 | 조회 780 | 2022.12.13
Christmas shopping is well underway and Fire and Emergency New Zealand is reminding people to be cautious around lithium-ion batteries."These batterie… 더보기

Tough conditions for new investment purchases

댓글 0 | 조회 825 | 2022.12.07
The latest CoreLogic Buyer Classification data shows continued struggles for mortgaged multiple property owners, but arelatively high % share of purch… 더보기

Daily Organics kombucha recalled due to highe…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,011 | 2022.12.02
New Zealand Food Safety (NZFS) is supporting Daily Organics in its recall of kombucha due to higher-than-permitted alcohol levels.“The issue with Dail… 더보기

These are the best broadband, mobile and ener…

댓글 0 | 조회 869 | 2022.12.02
Last night saw close to 300 senior-level professionals from across New Zealand’s Telecommunication and Energy sectors come together for the NZ Compare… 더보기

High mortgage rates and recession – a bad com…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,902 | 2022.11.28
The Reserve Bank of NZ (RBNZ)'s final Monetary Policy Statement (MPS) for 2022 took us all by surprise – not by virtue of actually raising the officia… 더보기

One-year fixed mortgage rates of 7% or more o…

댓글 0 | 조회 2,927 | 2022.11.23
Given the evidence that inflation is proving tougher to stamp out than was previously expected, it doesn’t come as much surprise the Reserve Bank of N… 더보기

Gang numbers highest ever recorded

댓글 0 | 조회 789 | 2022.11.22
Alarming new data shows that gang membership in New Zealand has hit its highest level ever recorded, National’s Police spokesperson Mark Mitchell says… 더보기

Resale performance still solid, but weakening…

댓글 0 | 조회 715 | 2022.11.17
The resale performance of residential real estate has continued to deteriorate, as the wider property downturn affects the ability of vendors to sell … 더보기

NZ first home buyers find silver lining amid …

댓글 0 | 조회 945 | 2022.11.09
Despite buying activity among New Zealand first home buyers (FHBs) falling to its lowest level since 2011, market newcomers have shown remarkable resi… 더보기

Almost a third of New Zealand homeowners not …

댓글 0 | 조회 1,467 | 2022.10.27
A new survey commissioned by independent property data and analytics provider CoreLogic NZ is giving detailed insight into Aotearoa’s established prob… 더보기

Health Quality & Safety Commission report int…

댓글 0 | 조회 823 | 2022.10.27
The Health Quality & Safety Commission (the Commission) has today released part 2 of its investigation into the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic o… 더보기

Pams brand sprouts recalled due to possible p…

댓글 0 | 조회 779 | 2022.10.26
Pams brand sprouts recalled due to possible presence of SalmonellaFoodstuffs Own Brands Ltd is recalling its Pams brand Alfalfa Sprouts, Salad Sprouts… 더보기

National will create a Social Investment Fund

댓글 0 | 조회 935 | 2022.10.19
Social investment will be the organising framework for the next National Government’s approach to the funding and delivery of social services, said Na… 더보기

Property downturn deepens, but important diff…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,256 | 2022.10.19
Decade-low sales volumes and fast-falling home values have deepened the housing market decline however some key dissimilarities between the GFC-induce… 더보기

Keep New Zealand Beautiful sets record year f…

댓글 0 | 조회 979 | 2022.10.18
Iconic Kiwi charity Keep New Zealand Beautiful (KNZB) is excited to announce the impact made during Clean Up Week 2022.Clean Up Week, which is New Zea… 더보기

Construction costs continue to rise, but peak…

댓글 0 | 조회 804 | 2022.10.14
CoreLogic NZ’sCordell Construction Cost Index (CCCI)for Q3 2022 showed further acceleration in the rate of indexed growth in national residential cons… 더보기

Omicron subvariant BQ1.1 detected in New Zeal…

댓글 0 | 조회 979 | 2022.10.13
ESR confirmed it has sequenced New Zealand’sfirst case of Omicron subvariant BQ.1.1 in a person who tested positive for COVID-19.BQ1.1 was also detect… 더보기

Girls living in conflict face 20% higher risk…

댓글 0 | 조회 728 | 2022.10.11
Girls affected by conflict are 20% more likely to be married than those living in peaceful areas, according to new analysis from Save the Children rel… 더보기

Ministry of Social Development (MSD) Child Po…

댓글 0 | 조회 774 | 2022.10.07
Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG) welcomes the findings in the latest MSD Child Poverty Report showing that material hardship rates for many children … 더보기

One year of OCR increases, with more to come

댓글 0 | 조회 834 | 2022.10.05
The Reserve Bank of NZ delivered another widely anticipated 0.5% increase in the official cash rate(OCR) today, taking it to 3.5% – the highest level … 더보기

National will extend free breast cancer scree…

댓글 0 | 조회 945 | 2022.10.04
The next National Government will extend free breast cancer screening for those aged up to 74 years, National’s Health spokesperson Dr Shane Reti and … 더보기

COVID-19 deaths analysis shows importance of …

댓글 0 | 조회 745 | 2022.10.03
An analysis of deaths from COVID-19 in New Zealand shows being up to date with your vaccines is the single best way to reduce the risk of dying from C… 더보기

New mortgage lending activity still very quie…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,171 | 2022.09.27
Given that property sales data for August has already beenavailable for a few weeks now – and it remained very weak – therewere no surprises to see th… 더보기

Unemployed West Aucklanders lining up to work…

댓글 0 | 조회 854 | 2022.09.27
The Ministry of Social Development (MSD) has worked alongside Costco to help it find some of the right people to staff its first New Zealand store.Loc… 더보기

New Zealand Flag to Return to Full Mast on 27…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,041 | 2022.09.22
A State Memorial Service in New Zealand for Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II will be held on 26 September.Following this, on 27 September, the New Zeala… 더보기

Northland house fire proves why smoke alarms …

댓글 0 | 조회 827 | 2022.09.21
Fire and Emergency encourages New Zealanders to check their smoke alarms this weekend when clocks turn forward an hour for daylight saving.Working smo… 더보기

First home buyers quietly returning to the ma…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,383 | 2022.09.20
First home buyers (FHBs) accounted for 25% of propertypurchases in August, their highest market share since Decemberlast year, and up steadily over th… 더보기

Property values plunge in more than 80% of Ne…

댓글 0 | 조회 1,637 | 2022.09.16
Aotearoa’s housing market downturn is in full swing, with most of the country’s suburbs recording a fall in property values in the past three months, … 더보기

Long COVID guidelines released

댓글 0 | 조회 935 | 2022.09.16
The Ministry of Health has releasedlong COVID guidelinesfor health professionals, individuals and those caring for people with long COVID, adding to t… 더보기

1,149 community cases; 225 hospitalisations; …

댓글 0 | 조회 859 | 2022.09.12
Today we are reporting 1,149 community cases and 225 current hospitalisations. The seven-day rolling average of community case numbers today is 1,480.… 더보기

1,483 community cases; 243 hospitalisations; …

댓글 0 | 조회 747 | 2022.09.09
Today we are reporting 1,483 community cases, 243 current hospitalisations.The seven-day rolling average of community case numbers today is 1,549. Las… 더보기

1,653 community cases; 254 hospitalisations; …

댓글 0 | 조회 644 | 2022.09.09
Today we are reporting 1,653 community cases, 254 current hospitalisations.The seven-day rolling average of community case numbers today is 1,595. Las… 더보기

1,793 community cases; 260 hospitalisations; …

댓글 0 | 조회 792 | 2022.09.07
Today we are reporting 1,793 community cases and 260 current hospitalisations.The seven-day rolling average of community case numbers today is 1,655. … 더보기

Call for views on releasing new exotic housep…

댓글 0 | 조회 996 | 2022.09.07
The Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) is asking people whether 12 exotic houseplant species should be allowed in Aotearoa New Zealand.New Zeala… 더보기

Conditions are starting to shift in favour of…

댓글 0 | 조회 719 | 2022.09.07
It’s still quite a big financial hurdle to move to a property with more bedrooms in most parts of the country – and in fact, it’s actually got worse i… 더보기